Hindi Literature - now, what's that ?? Almost all the bookstores I have been to in last few years, seem to be asking. It is almost depressing to see the shelf space given to books in our national language by these stores - in most cases, you will find hindi books in a single narrow shelf or two, in a corner. What is the reason of such apathy to our own mother-tongue, the language of the masses?
- Is it that people do not want to read hindi any more? I have come across people, who take pride rather than shame, in confessing that they cannot read hindi fluently - and these are people who have been taught hindi in school, and who usually converse in hindi. They have forgotten how to read their mother tongue, let alone write it. Incredulous, is it not?!
- Or, is it a dearth of good literature? This is a reason I find justifiable to some extent. I am yet to come across contemporary literature that suits my taste. This problem has two facets - the contemporary writing is not found to be up to the mark, whereas the classics seem to be totally out of context (I have devoured many novels of Premchand in my childhood, but I cannot read them now). Secondly, it does not seem to be as versatile - the genres and themes seem to be rather limited. For example, I am fond of thrillers, but all the ones in hindi seem to be cheap ones, and are definitely not researched for technincal soundness. Though I must admit that my views could be biased due to limited availability of good reading material.
Another observation I have made is the price - hindi books are available at throw-away prices. One may purchase short novels for less than 100 bucks. I saw 'Chandrakanta' available at 60 bucks, and each of 6 volumes of 'Chandrakanta Santati' at 55 - that is 390/- for 7 volumes! A point in case may be the recently published autobiography of Pervez Musharraf - the english edition costs almost thrice the hindi one (and its the same book!). Is it because the publishers are forced (by whatever forces of nature or politics or economy) to publish hindi books, so they keep the price as low as possible to enhance sales? Or are they subsidized to enhance readership? This I am not sure of.
***
Yesterday I read 'Chaudah Phere' by 'Shivani'. Although it was written almost 50 years ago, many things are still true in the context of Indian society - the unprogressive thought process of the people in small towns, the helplessness of financially and emotionally dependent women, the compulsion to continue a meaningless marriage, the stigma associated with extra-marital relationships, parent's desire to get their children married at "suitable age" preferably according to their choice and almost definitely within their community, and so on. There are incidents and thoughts that seem to be outdated, but that may be acceptable because of its setting in villages and towns in hills of Uttaranchal, and because it was written so long back.
It is a good story altogether, with bits of humor, and has a happy ending, unlike most of the stories of the same genre and era. I like haapy endings :-))
- Is it that people do not want to read hindi any more? I have come across people, who take pride rather than shame, in confessing that they cannot read hindi fluently - and these are people who have been taught hindi in school, and who usually converse in hindi. They have forgotten how to read their mother tongue, let alone write it. Incredulous, is it not?!
- Or, is it a dearth of good literature? This is a reason I find justifiable to some extent. I am yet to come across contemporary literature that suits my taste. This problem has two facets - the contemporary writing is not found to be up to the mark, whereas the classics seem to be totally out of context (I have devoured many novels of Premchand in my childhood, but I cannot read them now). Secondly, it does not seem to be as versatile - the genres and themes seem to be rather limited. For example, I am fond of thrillers, but all the ones in hindi seem to be cheap ones, and are definitely not researched for technincal soundness. Though I must admit that my views could be biased due to limited availability of good reading material.
Another observation I have made is the price - hindi books are available at throw-away prices. One may purchase short novels for less than 100 bucks. I saw 'Chandrakanta' available at 60 bucks, and each of 6 volumes of 'Chandrakanta Santati' at 55 - that is 390/- for 7 volumes! A point in case may be the recently published autobiography of Pervez Musharraf - the english edition costs almost thrice the hindi one (and its the same book!). Is it because the publishers are forced (by whatever forces of nature or politics or economy) to publish hindi books, so they keep the price as low as possible to enhance sales? Or are they subsidized to enhance readership? This I am not sure of.
***
Yesterday I read 'Chaudah Phere' by 'Shivani'. Although it was written almost 50 years ago, many things are still true in the context of Indian society - the unprogressive thought process of the people in small towns, the helplessness of financially and emotionally dependent women, the compulsion to continue a meaningless marriage, the stigma associated with extra-marital relationships, parent's desire to get their children married at "suitable age" preferably according to their choice and almost definitely within their community, and so on. There are incidents and thoughts that seem to be outdated, but that may be acceptable because of its setting in villages and towns in hills of Uttaranchal, and because it was written so long back.
It is a good story altogether, with bits of humor, and has a happy ending, unlike most of the stories of the same genre and era. I like haapy endings :-))
16 comments:
Couldn't agree more!
I once went to 'crossword' in Baroda(Guj). I was surprised to see tons of Gujarati books!I thought Crossword would be stacking Hindi books in its stores in the north!
May be not so many people buy books in Hindi but atleast the bookstores could try!
One way or other, I havent come across a Crossword store in Delhi. There certainly isn't one in Noida.
But why would the bookstores try ? They are there in business to earn a profit, not to serve the language or literature.
-Sigma
though I read a lot, haven't tried Hindi books. Reason - not that much fluent in Hindi.
Let me try reading Hindi books
OMG - this is too uncanny, I refrained from commenting on this...as the time when you were writing this - I had just picked "Yayati".
And while scrolling down just now your blog I see - you are meaning to read "Life of Pi" , which I just finished last week during travel time...
You will like that novel...read the author's note - its very interesting.
@Prashanth: You can try some smaller nice ones ... and soon we know, you'll be fluent enough to read the heavier ones ;-)
@BTR: Gosh!! So, what is 'yayati' about ? The mythical king ? Let me know how it is. Yes I mean to read 'The Life of Pi', having been encouraged by many friends by now. I am looking for some kind soul who'll lend it to me :-P ( or else I'll buy a copy :D )
Yayati - ok, I have read the story - as a child, in a 'Amar Chitra Katha'.
Thank you so much for your kind offer of lending me the book. But it is more trouble for you to mail it than for me to buy (specailly since I dont mind having a good book in my collection anyday :-))
Where can I find one NSD bookshop ?
And I am deleting your comment as you wished :-)
Thx first of all !
NSD Bookshop is @ Bhagwan Das Road near Mandi house - ask anybody for National School of Drama Institute walk in and go to their library and bookshop. They have the best collection of Hindi lit.
ps - ....and here I thought someone will invite me to coffee....@ Barista Noida :-)
I see. Thanks a lot for the info.
And I can still invite you to coffee even if I dont borrow your book ;-)
should I check my email....for the invite....lol....!
http://www.suyogdeshpande.net/blog/ - Go thru this link...very good book review posted by this guy on Sahitya Kala Academy winner...! Now this is what I would call to grab your own copy....are you aware that there is a Book Sale on Sahitya Kala Academy books.
Hi Sigma,
where you had found the Chandrakant Santati, i m looking for that, but unable to find the good place from where i can purchase.
Divyesh
Hello Divyesh, I am not able to access your profile (and hence your blog). Can you please leave a link.
I am not sure where you are based, so I might not be able to help you much.
I have seen Chandrakanta and Santati at Teksons in Noida, and at Book Cafe in Shopprix Mall in Noida. Another good source would be Book Fair - there are two that are organized annually in Delhi - India International Book Fair and Delhi Book Fair.
Funny.. I visit teksons almost every week and haven't noticed the hindi section (smack on head).. have been looking for these books frm a long long time.. going tomm to buy them :)
thanks a lot..
PS: found you while searching for places to buy chandrakanta
Hi,
I got Chandrakanta Santati at "rajkamal Prakashan Pvt Ltd", at Dariya Ganj. The good thing is thai i got the original copy, i mean they had just re printed the copies, so there is no chage in the text and story.
You can find me at
http://divyeshshah.blogspot.com.
For reference for others i am giving the address of the Publication house.
http://www.rajkamalprakashan.com/
at 1 B NetaJi Shubhash Marg, Dariyaganj, New Delhi.(23274463, 23288769)
Thanks,
I had tried to use this Font seletion in blogs... it is really good....
It seems that technology is moving with a greater speed and it is very tough to catch all those... :)
http://divyeshshah.blogspot.com
Post a Comment